It goes without saying that it is hard to find a tent with a balance between weight and quality. If you wish to have a lightweight tent, you usually have to sacrifice high quality. However, MSR Hubba Hubba vs Naturehike Mongar is two of many brands that can offer both toughness and lightness. Thus, your adventure will be safer, lighter, and more interesting.
Each of them has its own pros and cons. So, this article will help you make the best decision by listing out all their key features and a detailed comparison between the 2 types.
MSR Hubba Hubba vs Naturehike Mongar – Which is the best one?
In brief, I would love to buy a Naturehike Mongar instead of MSR Hubba Hubba.
Compared to Hubba Hubba, Mongar is more cost-saving with more wonderful durability. At a low price, it doesn’t have significant faults. Although its mesh is bigger than Hubba Hubba and I may get cold in the winter, I’m more interested in the big sky view. About the coldness, I just need to remember to bring my suitable sleeping bag or heat bag to keep me warm.
On the other hand, a costly MSR has some weaknesses that I cannot decide to buy such as weak poles and ineffective waterproofness.
MSR Hubba Hubba
See Latest Price
Key features
MSR Hubba Hubba is an ultimate backpacking tent as it is equipped with many helpful features.
The pole geometry, a non-tapered floor, and two large side-entry help maximize your living space. The unified hub-and-pole structure and color-coded clips have made setup easier than ever.
(Cre: Enwild)
Camping in unexpected conditions? Don’t worry because Hubba Hubba provides you with Xtreme Shield waterproof coating to keep you dry and clean. Its Easton Syclone poles made from new composite materials are promising to hold up in windy conditions. Besides, it won’t let you down on warmer days with better airflow thanks to the adjustable and cross-ventilating rainfly.
Pros
- Lightweight and compact
- Easy to set up
- Great air circulation
- Smooth zippers
- Spacious enough for 2 people
- Wide vestibules for extra storage space
- The unified hub-and-pole system is light and strong
Cons
- Small mesh design => Lack of sky view and clear visibility
- Expensive
- Thin fabric needs to be treated with careful attention.
- With the rainfly on, you need to lower your body to get in/out.
- Poles with poor quality => Not strong and safe in extreme weather conditions
- In the old version, it is inconvenient when the brand gave you a bottle of sealant and you had to seal it by yourself. => Not worth the high price
- Water leaked through the seams if you don’t seal them carefully.
- Silver splinters of poles are stuck in your hands. They are tiny and hard to remove.
Naturehike Mongar
See Latest Price
Key features
Known as an ultra-lightweight tent, Naturehike Mongar can surprise you more than that.
Mongar is made from high-quality fabric with added rip-stop for better durability. It also has plenty of room for you, your partner, and your gear thanks to 2 huge vestibules and pockets. Above all, setup can be done quickly thanks to the Y frame with a simple structure.
(Cre: Backpacking UK)
In addition, people love Mongar because of its super ventilation system with 2 doors, 2 air vents on each side, and super large mesh. These are designed to prevent condensation and bring more fresh air into the tent. The big mesh also gives you the best stargazing experience.
Pros
- Big enough for 2 people
- Purple is a unique and beautiful color
- Great ventilation to prevent condensation even with the rainfly on.
- Durable poles
- Easy to assemble
- A gear loft included
- The tent can hold up strongly in strong winds
- Great water resistance thanks to effective waterproof coating.
Cons
- 20D nylon thin floor => Needs to be treated with special care
- Super large mesh => Less privacy and more coldness in colder months.
- Low headroom => Not suitable for tall people
- Low-quality stakes with just a little pressure can make them easily snap => You should buy studier stakes.
- The fly doesn’t stretch fully to the ground. => Wind and dust can flow into the tent through the gap.
- Short center height => Inconvenience when getting in/out of the tent.
MSR Hubba Hubba vs Naturehike Mongar in comparison
Similarity
MSR Hubba Hubba vs Naturehike Mongar shares 3 notable points.
Firstly, you won’t have any difficulties during the setup and takedown process because of the unified structure. Every single pole is readily connected by the manufacturer. So, you only need to tension them properly.
Secondly, they are roomy enough to fit 2 people comfortably. In addition, they also have interior pockets and 2 large vestibules for extra storage space.
Thirdly, the two tents are full of praise for their excellent breathability thanks to 2 doors, a mesh design, and 2 big vents on the rainfly. Great airflow helped reduce condensation to the minimum. Besides, you can feel a cool breeze whenever the wind blows, while it is still warm inside.
Finally, they have one weakness in common – the short center height. Since their headroom is not really high, it may be unpleasant for you to get in or out of the tent, especially when the rainfly is on. A tall person needs to bend his back and crawl to go through the door.
Difference
Mesh size
Although MSR’s small mesh negatively affects the view and visibility, its insulation can keep you warm in colder months.
Different from MSR, Naturehike’s huge mesh goes nearly to the ground for you to enjoy a spectacular sky view. However, you are likely to feel very cold in the winter. Besides, dust or sand on the ground can easily enter the tent.
Water resistance
Naturehike is proof of a lightweight yet strong tent. Its water protection with silicone coating and 4000 mm waterproof index works truly well. As a result, the tent was completely dry even in a downpour.
On the contrary, MSR did not perform well in the rain. Some users faced serious leakages through the seams of the rainfly. Their stuff got fully soaked. Additionally, in the old version, what made users fairly upset is the fact that the brand gave them a bottle of sealant and let them seal it by themselves, given the high price of the tent. Luckily, MSR states that they have now sealed the seams. Hopefully, users can expect much from this improvement.
Poles & stakes
MSR Hubba Hubba’s poles are not praised much because of their poor quality. These poles are easily broken in strong winds or when they are not properly set up. As a result, you should be careful during the setup process. Due to the weak poles, MSR’s wind resistance also doesn’t work well. Your tent hardly can hold up stably and strongly in extreme weather conditions.
In addition, another annoying aspect of MSR poles is the silver splinters that are really tiny and hard to remove. They will be stuck in your hands when you hold the poles. However, users don’t see any advance warnings from the manufacturer. For this reason, it is advisable that you wear a pair of gloves to keep your hands clean while you are setting up/taking down the tent.
About Naturehike’s poles, they give users the feeling of high quality since they can withstand high winds effectively. People don’t see any confusing experiences with the poles. This is a huge strength of a lightweight tent-like Naturehike. Nevertheless, its small stakes are not strong enough as they snapped easily. Therefore, some Mongar’s users advised you to get harder and bigger stakes for extra stability.
Price
Currently, MSR Hubba Hubba’s price is about 3 to 4 times higher than Naturehike Mongar’s.
So, if you want to save your budget, don’t spend it on an MSR tent.
FAQs
1. Do I need to use add a footprint to MSR Hubba Hubba and Naturehike Mongar?
The footprint is highly recommended for every tent because it is helpful for maintaining the durability of the tent.
As mentioned above, MSR Hubba Hubba vs Naturehike Mongar is a lightweight tent. Their floor materials are fairly thin and likely to be torn due to regular use. Therefore, you should use a footprint to protect the floor better.
2. Do I have to use the guy lines included in the purchase of Naturehike Mongar?
No, you don’t need to use them because this tent is freestanding.
Actually, it depends on the conditions you go camping in. Guy lines with stakes are extremely helpful for stability and ventilation.
3. I heard that MSR Hubba Hubba in 2019-2020 had some leakage problems with its seams. Is this fixed in the latest model?
Yes, I am thrilled to know that all MSR tents’ seams are now sealed. Besides, they also use Xtreme Shield waterproof coating & precision-stitched seams for additional protection.
Conclusion
In summary, my recommendation would be Naturehike Mongar because, at a cheaper price, it has many positive comments about its high quality. Only 1 point you should remember is to bring your warm sleeping bags in the winter and buy stronger stakes.
In contrast, although MSR is way more costly, you cannot believe in its durability much due to the weak poles and water leakage. However, Hubba Hubba seams have now been sealed carefully. So, let’s wait for some good news from it later on!
Tags: Rightline Gear Suv Tent Vs Napier, ALPS Mountaineering Vs Marmot, Wenzel Vs Coleman Tents, Campros Vs Coleman, Geertop vs Naturehike, Geertop vs Lanshan, Vidalido vs Coleman, Alps Mountaineering vs Kelty, Core Tent vs Ozark Trail, Naturehike vs Big Agnes, Naturehike vs MSR, Thule Tepui Vs Smittybilt, Alps Mountaineering Vs Coleman, Napier Sportz Truck Tent Vs Backroadz, Big Agnes Blacktail Vs Msr Elixir, Naturehike Cloud Up Vs Mongar, Big Agnes Vs Marmot Tent, Msr Hubba Hubba Nx 2 Vs Elixir 2, Msr Hubba Hubba Vs Access 2, Kodiak Canvas Vs White Duck, Marmot Limelight Vs Tungsten, Coleman Sundome Tent Vs Dark Room Tent, Marmot Limestone Vs Halo, Coleman Sundome Vs Skydome, Marmot Limestone Vs Limelight, Forceatt Vs Bessport, Marmot Limestone Vs Tungsten, Big Agnes Vs North Face Tents, Coleman Sundome vs Flatwoods, ALPS Mountaineering Lynx Vs Taurus, ALPS Mountaineering Vertex Vs Velocity, ALPS Mountaineering Lynx Vs Zephyr, MSR Hubba Hubba vs Naturehike Mongar.
